- Evenly matched amounts of prettiness do not always add up to compatibility. To wit: Us Weeklyreports that Jake Gyllenhaal recently enjoyed a brief but ultimately unsuccessful romance with Minka Kelly."It was never serious," shrugs a source of the pair's handful of dates, "and it's over now."Too bad, because the actor, 31, had apparently been harboring a crush on the dark-haired looker, 32, for a while.According to the mag, he asked her out last fall, but she gave him the brush-off because of her on-again, off-again three-year romance with New York Yankees star Derek Jeter."Minka wasn't into Jake when he first pursued her," sums up an insider.